Testing expert Jack Bishop walks you through the different olive varieties.
Buy our winning Mezzetta Pimento Stuffed Olives:
Read our Pimento-Stuffed Green Olives taste-test:
Browse our latest recipes:
ABOUT US: Located in Boston’s Seaport District in the historic Innovation and Design Building, America’s Test Kitchen features 15,000 square feet of kitchen space including multiple photography and video studios. It is the home of Cook’s Illustrated magazine and Cook’s Country magazine and is the workday destination for more than 60 test cooks, editors, and cookware specialists. Our mission is to test recipes over and over again until we understand how and why they work and until we arrive at the best version.
If you like us, follow us:
41 Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
you are not just wrong you are stupid, I am Italian and every time I see an American talk about olives they say something stupid, black olives are delicious and every one in my family thinks the same, all olives are good but black olives are the best.
Black olives are the best on pizza
Do we really need some guy telling us what we should like? Think not…leaving.
I wish Jack was my uncle.
I see a lot of love here for the canned black olives. I agree. Always loved them as a kid. Jack must have not grown up when I did.
Best olives are kalamata, green are good if stuffed with feta, cream cheese or jalapeños.
Thank you.🤗🤗🤗💐🫶🏻💋
I despise olives, but Jack is just so compelling, I may have to give them another shot.
So basically the best Olives come from California?
Castelvetrano is the only olive I've ever tried that tasted good, instead of tasting like salty bile like the rest of them
I hate how lazy people are getting because all I see are pitted olives and really the best olives are with the pit.
A green olive brined with spicy peppers or Chalkidiki are my faaaav!
Сочный мощный восточный
My husband can sit and eat handfuls of pimento-stuffed olives…and I just can't. Now, black ripe olives stuffed with softened cream cheese is something my kids and I enjoy.
I love black olives! all all olives really !
What?! No canned black olives?? They are a staple for me. Why malign them? I’ve never considered them low on the totem pole😒 I demand you take back what you said about them, Jack!!
What about calamari olives? Awesome on Greek salad.
He didn’t give any tasting notes about the salt cured olives. Does anyone have any experience with them as compared to the flavor of the other ones?
Which kind of olive is best in a martini? Inquiring minds want to know.
I love all kinds of olives and I will say I even love canned black olives. I even drink the brine. They are not flavorless.
Don't forgetta Mazetta! I love their garlic stuffed.
I grew up with canned black olives, still love them, I used to get a can in my Christmas stocking, I could eat the whole can!
Good, helpful info. Excellently, concisely presented.
As I've gotten more into olives, I don't like pitted olives. It seems the brine becomes the dominant flavour instead of the olive. Of the bunch above, the salt / oil cured are my favourite since you can taste the oil in the olive.
If you do like olives, make Chicken Tagine with olives and preserved lemons. Use a mixture of black and green olives. Don't use pitted olives since they will probably turn into mush.
I'm guessing that canned olives also have their niche as well: Canned food can tolerate room temperature whereas salt-cured foods should generally be refrigerated. I'm also guessing that exposure to heat will also reduce the flavor and soften the texture of olives: In recipes that involve the application of heat, it might not matter so much and canned would be preferable if we consider the cost difference between both. <- Might also be a good idea for a future test video.
"Don't ever buy canned olives." What a food snob. Get real, Jack.
I love Jack and his segments. He is fun, interesting and very informative. One of my favorite stuffed olives are anchovy stuffed olives, so delicious!
my tradition is huge olive eaters and my background is ukranian born in argentina lol it is my first time i heard someone speak anout olives.
I consider canned olives a totally separate category from the rest of them- I love them equally, but differently 😀
I'm not a foodie but this castlevertrano olive are the bomb. So buttery and good. I stock up at Costco!
🫒 ❤
I was hoping this might be a taste testing for ppl like me who buy olives at the grocery store, and not so much an olive tutorial. Hmmm
Hate Castelvetranos. Giant lumps of flavorlessness. It's not the lye-cured olives that are the problem. Lye-cured can be excellent–nutty and crisp. The problem you have with them is that they're canned, which means they have to be retorted at high temperatures to keep them from developing botulism (they are too low acid to be safe in an anaerobic environment). Kept in brine and not canned, I've kept them for several months, with no discernible loss of quality. The canning process is the culprit. It tends to make them a bit mushy, though there are variations between brands. I did my first competitive (canned) olive tasting about 65 years ago, at age 10, at an annual Olive Convention in Santa Barbara.
My Dad's first job out of college, in 1936, was working as the plant chemist for an olive company in the San Fernando Valley. Even after he left there, when we could get fresh olives, he would lye-cure them. We loved them; all my friends used to love them, when I did them. Some even "borrowed" the recipe and cured their own. Unfortunately, I now live in an area that's marginal for olives, so don't have easy access.
One of my favorite open-faced sandwiches growing up was cream cheese and sliced green olives with pimiento on white toast (preferably Arnold Brick Oven White). It's so good you have to try it. Buy the whole. stuffed olives and slice them yourself. They even come in a low sodium version now so I don't feel so guilty when I indulge.
just love listening to jack bishop……..awe some man. He's always ready to burst out laughing. he makes me happy.
I recently started eating garlic stuffed olives and I can't stop……….. but the breath situation is pretty rough!!!
skimming through the comments, I feel as though I've discovered a new olive loving family. I disliked olives strongly for about 1/2 of my life and then have come to love their briney flavor. I just assumed due to my former tastes that people who like olives are in the minority but would like a longer olive episode. I have an olive tree so I wonder if it is super labor intensive to do the curing yourself
none mentioned jarred olives in the picture…..pure click bait….disappointed
I have an objection to the idea that castelvetrano olives are starter olives, as opposed to being recognized as just the best olives. I don't think them not being particularly challenging of a flavor profile makes them a chicken patty equivalent of an olive. Venison is more challenging of a flavor than Elk is, I don't think that means elk isn't obviously better than the comparable options.
What do you think of Goya extra Virgin organic olive oil?
Thanks for adding actual captions for the Deaf