On today’s episode, we have a special guest, Riddley, the editor on the team who tested braisers! She loves them because they are ready to tackle anything from chili to sautéed greens to shakshuka to roast chicken. Follow along as she and Lisa compare them to Dutch ovens and skillets.
Disclaimer: This video was filmed earlier this year and our team is currently working on exciting new content at home for the foreseeable future. Stay healthy and hope you enjoy!
Read the full review of braisers:
Buy our winning braiser:
Buy our best buy braiser:
ABOUT US: Located in Boston’s Seaport District in the historic Innovation and Design Building, America’s Test Kitchen features 15,000 square feet of kitchen space including multiple photography and video studios. It is the home of Cook’s Illustrated magazine and Cook’s Country magazine and is the workday destination for more than 60 test cooks, editors, and cookware specialists. Our mission is to test recipes over and over again until we understand how and why they work and until we arrive at the best version.
If you like us, follow us:
Riddley’s Instagram:
Lisa’s Twitter:
27 Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Disclaimer: This video was filmed earlier this year and our team is currently working on exciting new content at home for the foreseeable future. Stay healthy and hope you enjoy!
Staub is sooo much easier to maintain because of the black interior.
What can I cook in a 2.5 qt dutch oven… please help
If it's not Staub, I don't want it 😉
One of these presenters really does not have a voice for broadcasting. Lay Cruzzay! 😖
Can i saute salmon to get a crispy skin. Flip it then let it finish in the oven?
Oh my God the way the blonde talks annoys the heck out of me, somebody please change her batteries
Why are you using water. It has no flavor. Use stock or broth chef!
I can't understand how someone has a problem or issues with a dark interior like the Staub but yet be okay with non-stick cookware, carbon steel and natural cast iron for the last forever years of the past. If nothing else being a positive I bet the bottom of that darker interior is not going to be all stained up like the white ones in 10 or 20 years either. Just saying.
If you can manage cooking with non-stick , carbon steel and cast iron then the dark Staub interior is not going to be a problem.
So that side is called a Brazzer that's what side I bought today at the Goodwill it's about three and a half inches tall
I am so scared of all that fancy Dutch oven I bought one at the Goodwill today and it's good shape it's not as tall I think it's like a 4 quart or something it's a big side for me it's real big it's had not been cook in the bottom is green and on the side is green and inside is cream color I am so scared to cooking with it I am use of cast iron the black one you don't have to pray to use it or nothing you season it and everything go on with the flow I am so scared of using the Dutch oven with the cream color in it I don't want to mess it up so I just put it in the cabinet just look at it every now and then
I've seen some of these models that are offered with GLASS lids rather than cast iron. have you found serious disadvantages (or "glass half full" person that I am — any ADVANTAGES) to the glass lid? there is a Staub that is on sale but has the glass lid — which is why I'm asking. thanks.
The blonde has a very annoying vocal fry. Dump her and go with someone with normal speech.
thanks for making this video definitely is helping me put what I need on my list of fancy cooking.
The title of this video is spot on. My exact questions when I was searching about this.
I don't like hearing people using Valley Girl Speak. Ending a sentence with a lift at the end denotes a question when she is merely making a statement.
And where do I find that recipe for the braised pork??
I have the 5QT Le Creuset braiser in indigo blue and it looks gorgeous and the food tastes gorgeous. I’ve used it almost everyday since the day I got it couple of months ago. Handles so many recipes for the family – pad Thai, one pot pasta, zucchini noodles, curried paneer, paella, chunky soups, quesadillas, red and green shakshouka, stir fries 😋. I absolutely love it because it’s super easy to clean and it looks as good as the day I bought it (I only use wooden spoons and tongs). Besides it’s the only brand that passes California prop 65 standards. I wish we invested in it earlier in our life. We would have cooked more at home and been healthier for it.
i get tired of the throwaway comments – ceramic isn't as good retaining heat – and then X over a great product as if that's all viewers need to hear. and no explanation why a black surface is hard to see browning on but a white surface is ok with onions, etc – and the color means nothing once you start adding enough ingredients to fully cover the surface. how much contrast do you need to evaluate a pan full of sauce & chops?
She added raisins 😵💫
I have four utensils that will perform braising perfectly, so I certainly don’t need one of these.
You didn't test Lodge? Their braiser is identical to the Laaaaa Crewsay, and a third of the price.
Turns out, right now, a braiser is much more useful to me than a Dutch oven. I'm hoping to get the latter eventually as well but for now, anything I can do in a Dutch oven I can also do in a regular, big pot. But the braiser is great for finishing dishes in the oven or roasting meat and then making a gravy out of the burnt juices.
Hi hi just wondering if anyone can advice me if a braiser or a marmite is better? I’m considering of buying one or the other after the classic Dutch oven
I have the same braiser in red. Love it.
I recently made a nice sized pot roast in the le creuset braiser. Plenty of room for veggies too!
I have the Le creuset braiser and honestly if I could go back I would have bought the same braiser but with the glass lid. For what I use it for, which is stroganoff, chicken parm and sauces/gravy, the CI lid is overkill and just heavy. For something like a Dutch oven, yes get the CI lid, but for an everyday pan you use a lot for weeknight dinners in place of a skillet, go with the glass lid.