Want menus, recipes, and more tips? Visit Cook’s Illustrated Best Thanksgiving Guide:
Making a pie from scratch can be challenging—and by the time you get it in the oven, you don’t want to mess up the last step. Here are a few tips for knowing pie doneness: when your pie filling and crust are ready.
WATCH: Best Thanksgiving Gadgets
WATCH: How to Serve the Perfect First Slice of Pie
Know Your Oven Temperature
Ovens are inaccurate, and since all ovens cycle on and off to maintain temperature, even the best models may periodically deviate from the desired target by at least a few degrees during cooking. We recommend recalibrating your oven regularly, but in the meantime, a reliable oven thermometer will tell you what’s really going on.
The Crust
How do you know when your parbaked pie crust is done for your homemade pumpkin pie? For pies, it’s all about crust color. A well-browned pumpkin pie crust or pecan pie crust is more flavorful than a blond one, and it won’t be doughy in the middle.
The Filling
For both pumpkin and pecan pies, make sure that the filling is hot when added to the warm parbaked crust so that the creamy custard filling sets up quickly in the oven and doesn’t soak into the pie crust. For pumpkin pie internal temperature, bake until the internal temperature hits 175 degrees (use an instant-read thermometer). Be sure that the center of the pumpkin pie jiggles slightly; it will set up as it cools. For pecan pie internal temperature, bake the filling to an internal temperature of 185 degrees.
Cook’s Illustrated Best Thanksgiving Guide: