Our Taste Test of Supermarket Whole-Wheat Bread
Tasting expert Jack Bishop challenges Julia to a tasting of whole-wheat sandwich bread.
Read the full taste test of whole-wheat bread:
ABOUT US: Located in Boston’s Seaport District in the historic Innovation and Design Building, America’s Test Kitchen features 15,000 square feet of kitchen space including multiple photography and video studios. It is the home of Cook’s Illustrated magazine and Cook’s Country magazine and is the workday destination for more than 60 test cooks, editors, and cookware specialists. Our mission is to test recipes over and over again until we understand how and why they work and until we arrive at the best version.
If you like us, follow us:
Why didn't ATK consider Rudy's or Dave's?
From the similarities in their logos, I believe what you call Arnold’s is the same as Orowheat west of the Rockies.
The wheat has been processed and stripped of it’s goodness and has oxidized too much so the good hearty wheat flavor is not even the same. Not to mention all the additives they put back in to try and replace what has been milled out. Hence the bitter stale taste.
Orowheat/Arnold's is the best. Love it!
I think the weird thing with this category is that most people buy whole wheat bread or brands like Sara Lee in order to regulate their food consumption (whole wheat for more fiber and Sara Lee is a brand known for lower calorie products). Ranking the densest bread highest begs the question: why not just buy yummy white bread? That’s not that much fiber even in whole wheat bread. It’s like testing full fat whipped cream vs low fat whipped cream and saying full fat is the Best Buy. Of course it tastes yummier, but nobody buying low fat anything is doing so because it tastes better.
Anyone know the best potato bread? I've been using Old Tyme, and i like it. But is there something better? Many thanks in advance for any suggestions
Breads are getting to be like Ice cream. Puffed up.
Good observation.
You could have mentioned that Brownberry is the same product in the eastern USA. And at costco two loaves for $5.00.
I have had some 100% whole wheat breads that were too bitter to eat!
What the hell is Arnold’s bread??
This has nothing to do with real healthy brand
I only eat Sara Lee 45 wheat bread because I'm on weight watchers. But sometimes there's good size holes in the loaf.
Pepperidge Farm makes another whole wheat bread branded as “Whole Grain”. I greatly prefer it to the Farmhouse line, which I find too soft. And the Whole Grain brand has a top that’s similar to the Arnold’s line that was top choice in this video.
Arnold looks Oarweat bread
Please provide Closed Caption, for us hard of hearing individuals!
Miltex for the win!
Martins is the best…
Be careful of the unsaturated oil used in the bread! Soy, Canola and Palm are very very bad for you!
Yeah; I buy it. It's BETTER bar far than Sarah Lee. With Sarah Lee,all your buying is the name.
I'm glad i started pandemic baking. So much better, healthier and cheaper
I like Village Hearth 100 percent whole wheat bread in Nebraska
Only just saw this today. And you and others probably know by now but there is a big difference between whole-grain and whole wheat. Whole grain is the healthier more substantial option. Whole wheat is just garbage across the board.
The mission corn tortillas not the flour 😅
When comes down to it the best is MISSION TORTILLA WRAPS IS THE HEALTHIEST FOR YOUR DIGESTION NO WHEAT NO GLUTEN LOTS OF FIBER WHEAT IS NOT THE HEALTHIEST TO EAT
Pepperdine farm whole wheat is my favorite arnold not to bad Sara lee cakes are better don't knock Sara best pound cake 🎂
All yuk. Mush.
I can get Arnold bread for 99 cents a loaf at our local bread outlet store. It can seem a little dry compared to other breads.
I would never eat any Sarah Lee fake food
Pepperidge farm = The best wheat bread. Clutching my pearls right now!
The real crime here is $4.50 for a loaf of bread.
Brownberry/Arnold is very good. Trader Joe's wheat bread is also good (and, cheaper).
In the West, "Arnold" is also called "Oroweat", spelled without the letter 'h'.
Does Arnold 100% whole wheat bread package this Exact same bread for Aldi or Trader Joe
with their plastic sleeve ?
Or what other stores ?
Does Arnold 100% whole wheat bread package this Exact same bread for Aldi or Trader Joe
with their plastic sleeve ?
Or what other stores ?
Does Arnold 100% whole wheat bread package this Exact same bread for Aldi or Trader Joe
with their plastic sleeve ?
Or what other stores ?
No recipe links?
Private Selection™ 100% Whole Wheat Sliced Wide Pan Bread from Kroger or Ralph's is my favorite. At $1.99 for 1.5 pounds, it is also a great value. I found it after Arnold discontinued their Dutch Country whole wheat bread, which was really good, although very dense.
Only ATK uses calipers in the kitchen
Process breads
Wait… more expensive bread tastes better and is more dense?
Arnold's is Orowheat in the western US.
if you already have a video out of this, ignore, but I personally would LOVE a video on how to properly store, freeze & thaw different types of bread (ie traditional cut loafs of bread vs baguette etc), just a suggestion