The Best Burger Condiments | America’s Test Kitchen (S24 E25)
Tasting expert Jack Bishop shares his favorite burger condiments.
Get exclusive access to every recipe, review, and more:
Sign up for our free newsletters to receive more delicious recipes, cooking tips, and exclusive content:
ABOUT US: The mission of America’s Test Kitchen (ATK) is to empower and inspire confidence, community, and creativity in the kitchen. Founded in 1992, the company is the leading multimedia cooking resource serving millions of fans with TV shows (America’s Test Kitchen, Cook’s Country, and America’s Test Kitchen: The Next Generation), magazines (Cook’s Illustrated and Cook’s Country), cookbooks, a podcast (Proof), FAST channels, short-form video series, and the ATK All-Access subscription for digital content. Based in a state-of-the-art 15,000-square-foot test kitchen in Boston’s Seaport District, ATK has earned the trust of home cooks and culinary experts alike thanks to its one-of-a-kind processes and best-in-class techniques. Fifty full-time (admittedly very meticulous) test cooks, editors, and product testers spend their days tweaking every variable to find the very best recipes, equipment, ingredients, and techniques. Learn more at
If you like us, follow us:
A college classmate introduced me to Inglehoffer's coarse-grain mustard many years ago and I've never turned back.
I dislike Heinz ketchup. It has a bitter initial taste and a chemical aftertaste.
Give me Hunts! Add a drop of Inglehoffer's horseradish for a more complex kick.
Changing the subject a little, but try Mayo and sirracha mixed with a little lemon juice and topped with picked red onions and crushed potato chips.
I prefer steak sauce.
Blue Plate is salad dressing, not mayonnaise. If u want a southern mayo that’s not Duke’s, go for Hellman’s!
Personally, I prefer yellow mustard on a burger, over coarse ground or Dijon mustard. I like the sharp bitterness of the yellow. I just goes well with the meat.
Any condiment is fine if you like it, except for plain mayonnaise, which is disgusting , and if you think otherwise you are wrong.
All that matters is a medium rare burger and soft bun. That’s the minimum taste and texture. Screw that up and the whole thing is trash. Don’t get me wrong I love adding flavors but the bun and burger are everything
Since everyone else is adding their faves… HORSERADISH!
Yellow mustard, onions, pickles, lettuce and tomato. My favorite burger toppings. I gave up ketchup a long time ago (too much sugar) and have never been one for mayo. Cheese is OK but I can take or leave it.
How bout everything together? Let's get adventurous Jack.
Roasted Bell pepper fetta cheese on a over size english muffin. ❤ it
I was so disappointed on Kikkomans Sriracha. I bought it after it won the test kitcken. It's one of the worst srirachas I've tried. No idea how it won.
Ketchup and mayo is the best. Can even make a dry burger taste good.
Duke’s is my favorite mayo for sandwiches but hidden valley ranch” burger sauce” is the best condiment for homemade burgers.
Butter on a burger = heart attack city. 😂
Jimmy Buffett votes Heinz 57
Almost, Jack … but, not quite. 😄
— Take the "bun" out to the park, and feed it to the pigeons. They'll appreciate your generosity, as they have no discerning taste, and they seem to like "too much bread." Present your burger on sliced sourdough. It will keep the condiments in, without everything turning to bread mush. It will also add a touch of flavor.
— Mix A BIT of Mayo (Best Foods/Hellmann's) with A BIT of Ketchup. And, add A BIT of garlic to the mixture. (No fair buying commercial "1000 Island.")
— Add a thin layer of mustard-of-choice. (I like to let people make some of their own decisions 🤥)
— Slice some SHALLOT paper thin.
— Thinly slice a HOLY dill pickle. A "HOLY" dill pickle can only be found in a delicatessen, or at a butcher's counter, sold SINGULARLY. They are not available in jars, from the grocery shelves, with a commercial label.. (They can also be cured at home.)
— ENJOY !!
I make my own spicy and sweet (with a fruit included in the) sauce that I spoon over my homemade buffalo or venison burgers. Can’t say I would choose that butter option, especially not that much on a burger. Where’s the BEEF…flavor if you put all of that complex butter on both the meat and the bun???😉
Wait. “Organic” ketchup is laced with “more salt???” Is that why we pay more for it??? So, now I am wondering if the salt is organic as well???😵💫!😂😂😂😂
Nice lean burger for me, 90/10 Black Angus fresh ground , toasted bun w just a hint of mayo, lots of mustard,catsup, pickle, lettuce & ripe tomato.
Preferences for condiments are so much of a personal preference. Not so much a condiment, but blue cheese crumbles are fantastic. Another consideration is a steak sauce like Heinz 47 or A1 sauce. You can get the same effect from the steak sauce by mixing it in with the hamburger meat. And I personally won't eat a hamburger without dill pickles!
I like to add Worcestershire sauce to ketchup and mustard. Yummm.
Nice ad
Your mayonnaise picks both contain sugar. Not to mention "modified food starch" and "xanthan gum", etc., in your #1 pick, Blue Plate, but I mentioned them anyway. I had to look that up, because I've never heard of it. I looked up Hellman's long ago. Mayonnaise does not contain sugar. Use a mayo that doesn't have sugar. Mayo should have a tiny bit or tartness from vinegar (or lemon juice or something) and there is no need to offset that with sugar. This is the Curse of Miracle Whip, which has afflicted most mayonnaise brands. I use Duke's.
ATK out there doing gods work. 10/10