Equipment expert Adam Ried reviews one of our most used kitchen tools, the large saucepan.
Buy our winning saucepan:
ABOUT US: Located in Boston’s Seaport District in the historic Innovation and Design Building, America’s Test Kitchen features 15,000 square feet of kitchen space including multiple photography and video studios. It is the home of Cook’s Illustrated magazine and Cook’s Country magazine and is the workday destination for more than 60 test cooks, editors, and cookware specialists. Our mission is to test recipes over and over again until we understand how and why they work and until we arrive at the best version.
If you like us, follow us:
25 Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Americas Test Kitchen is owned by All-Clad by the way
I watch these vidoes, bought the all clad ss pan and its actually not great. Now i wonder if theyre paid by al clad and i got TRICKED???
Do the All Clad sauce pans pour easily or do they drip down the sides? I'm particularly interested in the 3 Qt and 1.5 Qt. Many thanks.
When are you going to get rid of the bash the pot on concrete block test? Dumb test. Who is going to do this at home? Try dropping it from 3 or 4 ft. onto kitchen floor. More likely!
ATK: You need to test Demeyere pans. They will eat All Clad alive !
Fully Clad pans have a big problem that ATK misses in their reviews : the walls get too hot and scorch sauces like a bolognese sauce or a thicker soup.
There is one AMAZING company that solves this: Demeyere: they have it on bottom only but wraps around the lower edge of the wall to prevent the burn they mention here. Demeyere also have an amazing technology that ensures the on never has a concave (central dome) when heated. try adding oil to an Al Clad fry pan all the oil will gather to the sides.
My #1 complaint about all pots, pans, utensils, etc. is any kind of a SOFT material on the handles. We've had several over the years … they ALL get soft and sticky over time. Now I will NEVER buy ANYTHING with a soft grip material on the handles.
I bought a pan and whacked it on a cinder block 3 times to test its durability. It got dented and scratched so I took it back for a refund. They refused the refund because apparently you should not be whacking your pans on cinder blocks.
Thanks to y'all its now $250!! haha
BS….The All Clad is NOW $244.95 on Amazon…Thanks for driving the price up. Been watching your videos and EVERY product you recommend, price is MUCH higher in no time at all. Any suggestions on this All Clad where it can be bought for less?
Does anyone know the name of the super heavy one?what brand it is?
Finally a review that fits my needs!
I often fail at making soup then spaz out and start smashing the pot on the ground! 😂
I now have a 100% All Clad. I've purchased them either used and or on sale. Lot's of money, but they make me a better cook, and my grandchildren will enjoy them.
$245 now at AMZ!
This 4qt pan is now $245.00 everywhere! The 3qt pan hasn’t gone up in price nearly as much.
The Allclad handles SUCK ! They are not comfortable, and the angle is so severe that you need to be at least 6 ft. tall to hold them. I don't like the valley is them either. I'm glad I only bought one to see if liked them or not before buying more. They are very well built, but the handles are a deal breaker for me.
You guys have discount code or something to get the $179? 😂
this thing is like $250 on amazon…..might as well go for the Multipiece D3 All clad kitchen set.
Is that price for real? I'm looking for something like D3 Skllet in the $100 range.
I’ve had All Clad pieces that that are 25 years old, and they still look and perform like new. Recently, I acquired some Demeyere pans, and like their form factor even more. Either brand will come on sale once or twice a year. Definitely worth it!
Several decades ago I purchased the same size 4 quart Alclad when I worked selling it for Marshal Fields, but in an anodized aluminum exterior. I don't think they offer the model any longer. It was one step from the top end series. I would point out that there have been military experiments that show dark pan heat 2x quicker than shiny surfaces. I prefer Alclad with dark exteriors and steel coated interiors. I would suggest buying the double boiler and steamer along with the pan if you can afford.
Hello. 😀
Why don’t up ever test Demeyer? They are by far the best brand. I recently noticed they also use them in the Bon Appétit test kitchen.
I'm looking for a large pot for making soup! Maybe 8 to 10 to 12 quarts. What do you recommend?
"Like holding a good tenis racquet." Is it me or was that the most yuppety thing you've ever heard lol
If you’re looking for a deal, the All-Clad D3 4qt soup pot is basically the same as the the 4qt sauce pot but typically runs half the price when on sale. The only difference is the soup pot has two helper handles instead of the long handle everyone hates. It’s a win, win.