What’s the Best Vanilla Ice Cream at the Supermarket?
Tasting expert Jack Bishop challenges host Julia Collin Davison to a tasting of vanilla ice cream.
Read the full taste test:
ABOUT US: Located in Boston’s Seaport District in the historic Innovation and Design Building, America’s Test Kitchen features 15,000 square feet of kitchen space including multiple photography and video studios. It is the home of Cook’s Illustrated magazine and Cook’s Country magazine and is the workday destination for more than 60 test cooks, editors, and cookware specialists. Our mission is to test recipes over and over again until we understand how and why they work and until we arrive at the best version.
If you like us, follow us:
Unfortunately they didn't test the best ice cream of all which is a company called Straus family Creamery which uses minimal ingredients without any preservatives, no artificial flavors, no food coloring, no fillers, & gluten free, imagine Haagen-Dazs if it was all organic. Strous'es organic vanilla bean consist of all organic cream, milk, sugar, egg yolks, and real vanilla bean specs. The organic premium ingredients gives you a taste that's an upgrade from Haagen-Dazs that you can notice. They don't have a lot of flavors ,13, although the ones they have are amazing. I haven't found a better coffee ice cream!
Duh turkey hill
Turkey Hill makes my favorite store bought ice cream of all time. I love it so much I can't even remember the name 'cause when I bring it home I inhale the carton very quickly – so I've not bought any in a while. It was a Covid discovery.. It's something like Double Dark Chocolate Espresso. The name says it all. Sprinkle some toasted slivered almonds on top and the result is just sinful.
This man’s a chef
Blue Bell is the best. Nothing comes close.
I always get my ice cream at Murphy's house of 9 flavors. My favorite is West Indian mocha licorice Delight
Blue Bell vanilla ice cream is the best
Costco vanilla ice cream beats all of these… our family favorite for years! 🍨🙌
Kirkland is the best
For a good store bought i'd say Tilamook!
Turkey hill for us
How do you keep homemade ice cream scoopable?
I vote for Tillamook French Vanilla.
After watching this, I have tried Turkey Hill and LOVE IT.
Blue bell!
Blue bell is superior to all the other brands
I don't care what anyone says but blue bell is the best ice cream and its not even close. If I can't get blue bell I will just not eat any.
Blue Bell "Homemade Vanilla", they're "Natural Vanilla Bean" flavor ain't nearly as good.
These "tastings" are terribly biased because most of these tastings are promoted by the brands they just happen to choose
I like Private Brand from Kroger's, vanilla is very good and their chocolate chip has lots of chips .
Nestle and it’s partners destroyed haagen dazs and Dreyers/Edys. As soon as they bought them, they reduced the butterfat content while maintaining the premium price. Dreyers vanilla used to be 16% but nestle reduced it to a cheap 10%. Shameful!
Hagan Daz the best.
Nothing compares to Blue Bell homemade. Absolutely delicious 😋
Love Blue Bell homemade vanilla.
Hey man I’ve tried almost all of these brands and blue bell is the best but the absolute best grocery store vanilla is Aldi super premium vanilla (black carton). And it’s way cheaper than most comparable brands. Do yourself a favor and try it. I got fed up with lack of taste so I started buying different brands after the blue bell issues a few yrs ago. Tried Costco trader joe Häagen-Dazs is ridiculously expensive and after trying just about every brand I decided to give the Aldi super premium brand a chance. As soon as I tasted it it was exactly what I envisioned a great vanilla tasted like. Heavy fat creamy sweet buttery flavor with great aftertaste also. And you really taste the vanilla (French).
Häagen-Dazs stands above the rest as long as the store didn't let it melt in their freezers. The store can ruin any ice cream if they don't keep it frozen
No Tillamook vanilla ice cream?! – Your testing is incomplete. I expect more from ATK