Ingredient expert Jack Bishop talks frozen seafood.
ABOUT US: Located in Boston’s Seaport District in the historic Innovation and Design Building, America’s Test Kitchen features 15,000 square feet of kitchen space including multiple photography and video studios. It is the home of Cook’s Illustrated magazine and Cook’s Country magazine and is the workday destination for more than 60 test cooks, editors, and cookware specialists. Our mission is to test recipes over and over again until we understand how and why they work and until we arrive at the best version.
If you like us, follow us:
50 Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Can you guys do a video on the best videos
How can you tell if you buy frozen halibut if it’s Freezer burn ? I need your help. Ms. Willie Cobb
color on the side pieces
i know talking about fish here,but what about previously frozen chicken i see in the super market labeld , previously frozen,usually chicken breast, my question is is it safe to refreeze it since im not going to cook them that day ?
Why when I sauté Cod does it come out tough and rubbery? When I sauté Salmon or Tilapia, it's fine.
Makes one wonder why our tax dollars pay for an organization like the FDA! We talk about other countries but our country and government has lost its credibility.
Left out wild caught or where farm raised can be trusted
Google tilapia farms and you will be horrified.
Thank you for the valuable information. I always thought frozen fish is inferior.
Why we still want to eat farm raised frozen??? instead of wild caught!
You don't mention scallops! Do the same rules apply to buying sea scallops?
I saw this video and decided to try the frozen salmon filets offered at a large popular supermarket chain in Connecticut, USA. I have always bought the fresh filets at the seafood counter. The first meal using the frozen salmon was awful. I generally cook this kind of fish in a covered pan with broth around it and it comes out very moist and tender but the thawed salmon filets were missing that tender texture. Today I put both a thawed filet and a fresh filet into an instant pot for a cook time of one minute with a fast pressure release. The fresh filet was what I expected and was excellent but the thawed filet was very dense in texture and not a pleasure to eat at all. The only reason that I ate it is that I refuse to waste food. So why the big disconnect between the advice in the video and the results?
I will never buy can clams anymore after tasting frozen clams from an Asian market in Gardena, CA
I'm having a lot of trouble finding frozen shrimp that doesn't contain STPP. What would my next best option be? Go for the ones sitting behind the counter or just get the frozen ones with the STPP?
Saute cod fish
Not sure about defrosting fish in the microwave, but you can make a really tasty poached filet straight from frozen in the microwave – fat, salt, aromatics, and something wet, like soy sauce or lemon juice, covered, cooked at 40% power for a few min depending on thickness (shout out Dave Chang).
Great teaching, this was needed
Taking the shell off and deveining manually is such a chore though
Frozen salmon was on sale in my grocers freezer I was assured it was not farm raised. In my fridge I thawed 2 fillets for 24 hours, took the fillets out, leaning them into my sink to drain liquid before cooking, both fillets went from salmon pink to brown, this pink colored goo drained out of the fish! It was the most disgusting thing I'd ever seen and I can only imagine what that thick pink goo was. I took it back to my grocers and even the manager was horrified. Don't buy farm raised.
Farm raised tilapia is not frozen on the ship 🤣 Your opening statement is littered with false information.
🤔
I always pull my shrink-wrapped flash frozen fish the night before, and leave it in the refrigerator, for dinner the following night.
For shrimp, I just take a tall drinking glass, and drop the frozen shrimp into the glass, put it in the refrigerator for the next night; it's perfect and ready to go.
Got rid of the microwave last year
I only buy Gulf Shrimp, and for a good reason.
No no for Tilapia. Especially farm raised Tilapia.
My problem with frozen shrimp: they seemed to be puffed up with water, I assume under pressure. "Large" frozen shrimp shrink to half their size once you put them in a hot pan. Because I live on the coast, I buy my shrimp fresh off the trawler, head them, and freeze them myself. No packaged frozen shrimp for me.
I thought there was a way to soak stuff that has that trisodiumphosphate such that it removes the off flavor. Seems like I've read about doing this with frozen scallops. Now I have to go research this further…
i live in kansas and work in a grocery store. all of our seafood comes in frozen. even fresh water fish.
IN MY VIEW
I bought my first frozen bag of seafood when the shrimp was on sale. My freezer now has a variety of seafood. This is SO convenient! I never go to the fresh seafood counter anymore. Your suggestions were great. I will look at my shrimp ingredients from now on to make sure it is only shrimp (salt is ok).
No need to defrost. Straight from freezer to a 430-degree oven for 30 minutes.
Wow! Tilapia (garbage fish)
Use your air fryer, no defrosting!! Amazing 15 minute shrimp fried rice!
All chef's making a fish meal use nice thick filets! Stop pushing skinny tilapia so the rich get the nice thick fish filets!
That one woman at the end saying to the butch woman, "I'll see you later!" Sounds like she's saying it's sex time later!
No farm fish …
Great advice. Once frozen, not twice frozen.
Jack did not cover a number of points. Be sure to read the comments about Wild Caught versus Farmed and … well, see for yourself. Thank you, commenters!
With little time to scour previous comments for the same observation and with an aim to inform even if to point out again…
Freezer burn is not as described…
The thing described, partially thaw and refrozen is dangerous and avoided at all costs…
Freezer burn is " the sublimation of moisture in a subfreezing environment where frozen water is converted directly from solid to gas"…
The dry air in the freezer is sucking the water right out of the food, even ice cubes shrink and the "frost-free" function of the freezer whisks it away…
A vacuum chamber in a freezer would accelerate the process and I think I just invented a new way to create beef jerky…
As you were….
When buying shrimp, it also helps to know the sizing system which tells you approximately how many shrimp you'll get per pound. Tiny shrimp will be labeled 61/70 which means 61-70 shrimp per pound. I usually go for 26/30 if I'm doing scampi and 16/20 for a shrimp cocktail…unless I'm trying to impress someone, then I'll go for 13/15 which are huge.
Would have been nice if he mentioned the quality assurance that the BAP certification seal offered. Thank You
Commercial fishing is destroying fish populations around the world. You shouldn’t be buying any seafood.
From the guy that thaws shrimp for sale at Kroger I agree with you!
Great tips ; Thank you ! ❤
Great stuff…just never eat Tilapia
My forays into frozen fish from my local supermarket were lackluster. I thought maybe it's the brand, so I bought a bag of frozen wild-caught salmon fillets from Whole Foods, thinking maybe the quality would be better. I wasn't happy with the pan-fried results – too "fishy" tasting. I know that sounds ridiculous, but you know what I mean. (I cook and enjoy salmon all the time – these had an unusually strong and unpleasant "fishy" taste – must have been the particular type of salmon).
So here I was with a freezer full of frozen haddock and salmon fillets. What to do? I know! I'll make soups and stews.
First up was a Thai fish bouillabaisse with lime, coconut milk, a cup of water, Thai peanut sauce (recipe called for red curry paste but I'm not a fan of super-hot and spicy food), cilantro and packaged broccoli slaw, to which I added a couple of the frozen salmon fillets. Delicious! Next, a Mediterranean fish stew starting with mirepoix and chopped garlic, then canned chopped tomatoes, a couple of cups of water, quartered small new potatoes, white wine, Mediterranean herbs and a couple of the haddock fillets. Yum!
Both recipes called for cutting up the fillets before adding them but I just dumped them in, whole, frozen. How convenient! The haddock was easy to break into pieces after it cooked. I removed the whole salmon fillets when they were cooked, turned them upside-down on a plate and removed and discarded the skin which practically slid off, cut them into chunks and dumped them back in the soup pot.
I now think this is a perfect way to use frozen fish fillets, especially if they're less than optimal when cooked using other cooking methods. A good glass of wine and some toasted bread slices as accompaniments make a wonderful meal.
Amusing that he's worried about what's added to the shrimp, but eats tilapia.
Hi Jack,
Sodium Tripolyphosphate, is used to make seafood look firm, smooth and glossy.
Seafood packers may soak product in a bath of STPP to achieve this. Seafood soaked too long will absorb more water so you pay more because it weighs more.
Product soaked with STPP will exude a milky white liquid as you cook it, and will shrink in size too.
Thanks Jack,
LG
how do you like eating frozen seafood from china… thats been package,god only know when. and where!!!!! ill take the fresh and local please. larry !!!
Ok, but what does freezer burn look like?
Some good tips but a lot of plastic. Also, no mention of COO. I shy from any food product from China.
I think he misspoke here when he said to run the tap water over it for 20 or 30 minutes. That’s an EXTREME waste of water. Also, I’ve never seen frozen shrimp sold in big blocks of ice. Is that even a thing? Finally he says don’t buy swordfish, tuna and maybe even salmon frozen? How are you supposed to buy it – given that his premise is that all fish are frozen on the boat anyway?