Best-Ever Chicken Pot Pie | America’s Test Kitchen (S24 E11)
Chicken pot pie usually requires a major time commitment. Our trusty Dutch oven proved to be the key to an easier way.
Get our Chicken Pot Pie recipe:
Get exclusive access to every recipe, review, and more:
Sign up for our free newsletters to receive more delicious recipes, cooking tips, and exclusive content:
ABOUT US: The mission of America’s Test Kitchen (ATK) is to empower and inspire confidence, community, and creativity in the kitchen. Founded in 1992, the company is the leading multimedia cooking resource serving millions of fans with TV shows (America’s Test Kitchen, Cook’s Country, and America’s Test Kitchen: The Next Generation), magazines (Cook’s Illustrated and Cook’s Country), cookbooks, a podcast (Proof), FAST channels, short-form video series, and the ATK All-Access subscription for digital content. Based in a state-of-the-art 15,000-square-foot test kitchen in Boston’s Seaport District, ATK has earned the trust of home cooks and culinary experts alike thanks to its one-of-a-kind processes and best-in-class techniques. Fifty full-time (admittedly very meticulous) test cooks, editors, and product testers spend their days tweaking every variable to find the very best recipes, equipment, ingredients, and techniques. Learn more at
If you like us, follow us:
God bless you but that is too much work. You lost me on the lattice part. Looked like crochet 🧶
I'd like to find a recipe where the sauce isn't thin & runny like soup and the flavor mimics Stouffer's Chicken Pot pie of yesteryear.
What size stock pot?
I got tired just watching this recipe Keith. Sorry. Sticking to my frozen pie crust so I can actually eat it the same day. No kitchen sheers required.
My goodness, so many steps in this are completely and utterly pointless! First of all what they're making is not a pot pie. Pot pites have a bottom crust. Then then they make and cut a lattuce to fit a round pot (pointless). They then and move it off of a baking sheet and onto a lid (pointless). I mean, It was already on a baking sheet, and there was no reason to make it round. Then they put the crust into the pot (pointless). Just to awkwardly cut it with scissors and move it over to a plate anyway. Ater spooning the stew over which was made more difficult because the lattuce was in the way. What is happening here? Just make stew. Bake lattuce. Put stew in bowl. Put lattuce on bowl. Done.
The most flavorful chicken pot pie I’ve ever made used leftovers from a batch of Cornell Chicken and Syracuse Salt Potatoes.
This seems pretty brilliant I must say, I'm so hungry now. It's hard to imagine that topping as good as the test kitchens old version though, yes that topping is a pain, so sticky but dear-god it's so rich, so buttery!
This isn’t new. I’ve been doing this for years. Try making the puff pastry separately in strips and then scooping the filling when eating so no soggy crust
Why yes, that did end rather abruptly. The last 30 seconds:
Keith: Oh, that puff pastry is so buttery and rich and flaky, the perfect complement to that thickened gravy underneath.
Julia: Keith, this is spectacular. Thank you!
K: You're welcome.
J: So, if you want to make the most elegant chicken pot pie, start by making a lattice top using store-bought puff pastry. Use boneless, skinless chicken thighs in the filling, and bake the lattice on top of the overturned pot lid while the filling cooks. From "America's Test Kitchen," an elegant, lattice-topped chicken pot pie with spring vegetables.
J: Definitely gonna make this for a special occasion. Like my parents — they would love this!
K: They would love it.
I love learning a new way of doing standard recipes. Thanks for the suggestions.
Bottom crust hill-diers: Why must a pot pie have one? If it has a bottom crust, isn't that just 'pie'? Otherwise, what's the distinction? A pot pie suggests the pot (or bowl or ramekin, etc) is the containment with a top crust that makes it a 'pie'.
(Theory: 'Pot pie' is just fun to say'.) 🤷♂
Also: Shepherd's Pie and Cottage Pie would like a word.
I think you have to be careful when touting something as “The best ….ever”, even in YT land because you’re going to get a lot of comments like you see here. Especially when messing with a classic. Just call it an “updated” version or a “new twist”. And, of course, “better” is in the eye of the taster! No homemade crust takes two hours to make! 😂 If your goal really is to “streamline” just use a store bought crust. Making a lattice crust of any kind is not “streamlining”. While the puff pastry looks different than a traditional crust and, perhaps, provides some “wow”, it certainly does not give the same palate effect or taste. I think this might work better for small, individual serving dishes where the crust/filling proportions are less, but that’s not “streamlining”. Having a single crust as opposed to two also takes away from what many (most?) folks find desirable in a chicken pot pie – a means to soak up sauce, though one v. two is a hot debate. The idea of using the lid as a cooking surface for the crust is a fail for me. First of all, I think part of why your “filling” was a bit soupy was because it didn’t get to “cook down” with the lid on for that short amount of time. In a Dutch oven, over time, sauces will cook down and thicken. I don’t think you have time for that in 25-30 minutes. Normally your filling is thickening and steam is releasing through the crust. Filling ingredients are probably as hotly debated as one v. two crusts. Tarragon, bay and asparagus all together seems pretty overpowering IMO. Also, I have never left puff pastry in a 400 degree oven for 25-30 minutes. Surely it would burn. So you’d need to take it out before the “filling” is done anyway and your thought that you’re somehow saving a dish or time or whatever is moot. I will say, if you are going to do this whole lattice top thing, I do like the idea of using the kitchen scissors to cut it for service. That’s the only positive here IMO.
I always add thyme to my chicken pot pie.
The comments didn’t pass the vibe check! They were going for more of a spring taste! Good job!
Lord people use some lard and make a crust. Top and bottom . No asparagus. I love asparagus but not there .
How about a tutorial on convectional cooking vs convection cooking since so many stoves have convection now?
Why couldn’t you bake the lattice crust right on the sheet pan it was on???
Another recipe with 55 ingredients . . . .
I love the new take on this classic. But I did have to chuckle a bit when you said “we are going to streamline chicken pot pie.” Then proceeded to start with a lattice crust. 😂
Delicious ❤
OCD Chicken Pot Pie!
Where do you get the butter puffed pastry dough? I have looked in all our grocery stores and the don't carry one that has any butter in it. Or could you suggest a brand that I could order over the internet? Thanks, Juli 🙂
This looks amazingly great 👍
It was all going soo well until the terragon came out. ruined it!!
Ok, whose idea was it to use the lid to bake the lattice? You're a genious!❤
I like peas and asparagus, but putting 5 vegetables in a chicken "pot pie" … it's just too busy, replace the peas and asparagus with green beans and you have a winner.
How in the world does it take “two hours” to make a pie crust?? My lovely wife does it in 10 minutes. Lol.
@Josh Johnson…
This is not a recipe for a home cook who has a job or children.
This is a joke. 😂
Two hours to make pie dough 😂 I can do it in 20 minutes.
That “pie” needs way more crust to be considered a pot pie. Y’all forget half the crust.
Wow is all I can say, the puff pastry lattice top is over the top gorgeous. Looks so delicious and inviting. I really enjoyed this video and may just give it a try. Thanks for sharing.
While my granddaughter and I love asparagus, my husband detests it. I was wondering if broccoli might work in it's place?
Two hours to make a pie crust? Oh please. Take one-half of a box of Jiffy pie crust mix. Mix. Roll out. Freeze the other half right in the box for the next pot pie. Filling: saute chopped onion in butter. Turn it into 1 or 2 cups of cream sauce, depending on how big your dish is. Add herbs and seasoning as desired. That's where the love comes in, and I don't mean soy sauce. Add leftover cooked chicken torn into small pieces. (It's probably a good idea to warm it up in the wave.) Add frozen peas or mixed vegetables, nuked to get rid of ice. Put it all in a dish. Cut vents in the crust. Bake at 375 till crust is nice and brown. Salt at the table as your blood pressure allows. I think the Jiffy box calls for 425, but why make the dish dangerously hot when a lower temperature will do the job?
Seems like a fake way to make a chicken pot pie. I think a pot pie should have a crust under it as well. Where is that? I think that a Marie Calender's would be better.
Sorry, ATK, but that’s NOT chicken pot pie. That’s a chicken casserole.
Pies have bottom crusts, so without a bottom crust it’s not a pie.
Asparagus?! I’m calling the police.
Doing this extensive "off pie" lattice seems like more work and honestly the end result isn't even a chicken pot pie.
I MIGHT have given them a pass if there were crust on the bottom, but no dice.
Chasen's, a famous Los Angeles restaurant, use to make chicken pot pies in is ~5" souffle dishes and then had a puff pastry crust rolled over the top and adhered to the top edge with a 1" hole in the center, so the puff pastry was suspended above the liquid. For the chicken base they would put in baby carrots, a baby turnip and some other small version of a vegetable all in a precious presentation. These were served annually at The Huntington Library Fellows dinner every year in the 1980s, so this, at least the baking of the crust, I think, was all performed in tents at the library. Those were the days, my friends.
Adding the lattice to such a deep pot seems clunky. I would've tried to put it in an enameled 9×13 pan instead.