Equipment expert Adam Ried discusses the best of our MVP in the test kitchen, the rimmed baking sheet.
Buy our winning rimmed baking sheet:
ABOUT US: Located in Boston’s Seaport District in the historic Innovation and Design Building, America’s Test Kitchen features 15,000 square feet of kitchen space including multiple photography and video studios. It is the home of Cook’s Illustrated magazine and Cook’s Country magazine and is the workday destination for more than 60 test cooks, editors, and cookware specialists. Our mission is to test recipes over and over again until we understand how and why they work and until we arrive at the best version.
If you like us, follow us:
31 Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
"Our winning one was $14"
*Click the link*
[it's $24 now]
INFLATION SUCKS!
0:40
1:08
Did i see wrong that back look like brown in the back baking sheet
The Nordicware baking sheets are excellent, but DO NOT get the Libertyware cooling racks. The quality is dubious at best, outright dangerous to use at worst. Uncommon L from this channel
"drying rack fits perfectly" … proceeds to show it not fit at all. O_O
There was a review on amazon where they showed that the metal literally came off the recommended Nordicware sheets with each wash and that they were having metal problems in their body. They showed multiple towels with the metal coming off with each wiping – it was kind of disgusting. Did you test for this? You need to verify this because if it's true, that could be a horrible health hazard.
Aluminum pans are unsafe. Stainless steel as a way to go. Do your research. Thanks for sharing
That rack does not fit "perfectly". I wouldn't buy a rack that fit like that. It appears identical to mine and I remember buying in a two-pak, so I suspect that the difference is in the sheet pan. My sheets came from a restaurant supply. Nice and heavy and don't warp. But there are no brand marks.
I am looking for a great sheet pan. I keep hearing about Nordic ware ..
I just learned how to season new baking sheets with a little bit of oil, and what a difference it makes in how they perform. I'm going with Vollrath pans as they supposedly warp in a way that sheds oil and juices to the corners of the pan rather than pooling in the middle. We'll see if that is the case.
I have the Nordicware and can say they are very well built; however, ATK’s choice in wire rack is weird. Yes it’s oven safe but according to the company’s specs it’s chromed. You can find 18/8 304 stainless that is oven/broiler save for about the same price.
Where is the link for cooling racks?
I am sending a baking gift set with baking sheets and a cooling rack. I want to send the best. Where do I go for that information? America’s Test Kitchen…. Only ATK. Such good testing and explanations. Thanks again!
I have two of those half sheet pans with the lines on them and I have ordered two of the Nordic Ware bakers have sheet. I will still continue to use my others because they work just fine. 🙂
Please recommend one tray and rack combo coming in at max $3….we ain't all rich I'm afraid! 😆
Just what I needed; perfect examples in black and white
WHERE do you buy the liberty ware half sheet cooling rack from???
The number 1 pick is made from aluminum though and I have heard that aluminum can leach into the food.
I'm stuck with a 24 inch oven, so I went with NordicWare and Libertyware quarter-size…not gonna lie, they're amazing, alone ore combined.
Why is it ok to use alumin(i)um here when most cooks dont like alumin(i)um pans to cook?
It fits perfectly.. IT WAS A BARGAIN!
Cooling rack that lay slanted are annoying
Literally JUST picked up my Nordic Ware at Target.. but not before first watching their October 2016 review! I always consult the Test Kitchen first! 💁🏽♀️
Nordic ware half sheet: $14.97 in the US, $46.98 in Australia
I can't find the cooling rack and there's no link to it. Where can I find it??? Anyone know?
Everybody appreciates a nice rack, but that cooling rack has roughly 1,200 individual squares, each of which must be cleaned after cooking your sticky BBQ pork. I prefer racks with parallel "bars" in just one direction, which are much easier to clean.
Odd that your pictures show using parchment paper??????????
Would have liked to see them sit something heavier on the racks. Also is there any issue with just getting racks form Nordic?
IM LOSING MY MIND! HOW can they suggest a rack that doesnt fit and then say it fits perfectly? Is his last name TRUMP? Sometimes i wonder how much they care about testing compared to their income from sales. Just sometimes… Anyway I wish I knew which kind mine were because i need more and mine DO fit perfectly WOW Unreal
The Checkered Chef Cooling Racks have three supports and not the Liberty Ware, which has two supports.
Is the liberty cooling grid the GRA4 (chrome plated) or the GRA4-SS (Stainless steel)? (Or GRA2/GRA2-SS)?
I like the lady best when she reviews. This guys voice is jarring